Since AY has made the decision to be such a light blonde (which suits her), and naturally has a fair complexion, I'm very surprised that she chooses such harsh contrast eyeliner. She has the sense to choose light lip colours, so it really does puzzle me why she wears jet black eyeliner and mascara. It drowns out the colour of her eyes and enhances her eye bags.
The whole myth of everyone should wear black mascara/eyeliner is just nonsense, and does so many women no favours at all!
You may be guessing that this is one of my pet subjects - and it is!
I always think that makeup should enhance the person wearing it, not smother their natural beauty, and if the first thing you see is stark eyeliner, or jarring plum/scarlet/whitey nude lips, then it ain't doing the wearer any favours! (Rant over).