With me I think it's the style of cleanser that's important, I was using Liz Earle C&P for years but had stopped buying the TSV's many years ago, and picked up what I needed in John Lewis. I have now switched allegiance to Emma Hardie which I find such a pleasure to use, smells very much like Decleor oils IMO, a little goes a very long way when mixed with water and works well with my new Clarisonic. Due to my age I thought I had better start using an eye cream and a night cream, so went for the starter kit first then the TSV to try. I like it all snd have one in the go and one spare, but just one eye cream ehich I use a pea sized amount of once a day. I don't feel I am old enough or ready for any serious anti- ageing products ( and do wonder about whether they work or not) but If I were in the market for that I would probably choose the Judith Williams based on what I have seen, sizes and price. That would just be creams though as I adore a hit cloth cleanser. I did try the boots one but was underwhelmed so gave it to my mum who likes no 7.
With the l'Occitane we have one liquid soap in the bathroom and one in the kitchen ( we don't have en suites or a downstairs cloakroom in our house) but the bottles do go down fast because the whole family used the Verbena one. I always used to get a dry chapped, eczema like rash in between my fingers, also little blister-type rash when I used other soap or handwash. It was embarassing and there was no point in wearing pretty rings with hands like that. Once I started using the liquid soap it cleared up completely, so I will stick with it. I get it in TSV's or duos so tes it is more expensive but I would rather not have the rash on my hands so I am happy to buy.
My husband and children also pinch my l'Occitane shea shower gels but they leave the Almond Oil one just for me!
With the exception of my husband and children, thanks to recent TSV's or other special prices sets my christmas and birthdays for family is almost sorted.