Bensmum
Registered Shopper
Top - Julian, Pippa and Kathy T.
Bottom - All the rest of them (I know its more than 3 but I just can't decide).
Bottom - All the rest of them (I know its more than 3 but I just can't decide).
Which presenters are your top and bottom 3?
- Thread starter speckledhen
- Start date
Help Support ShoppingTelly:
phoebelondon
Registered Shopper
- Joined
- Dec 17, 2011
- Messages
- 22
Top - Debbie Flint - what a woman! funny, attractive and you just want to be her mate
Pipa - downright fun
Ali Young - bossy but useful info
bottom - julia roberts - ego
dale franklin - patronising wanker
jill franks - don't get me started....
Pipa - downright fun
Ali Young - bossy but useful info
bottom - julia roberts - ego
dale franklin - patronising wanker
jill franks - don't get me started....
Akimbo
Fluffy
- Joined
- Jun 24, 2008
- Messages
- 10,447
Lottie
Silly Moo
Tops:
Julian, Anthony Heywood, Ali K, the 2 Debbies
(sorry couldn't cram it into 3)
Bottom
Screechy Women (AY, AD)
Too slimy by half (charlie, JF)
Julian, Anthony Heywood, Ali K, the 2 Debbies
(sorry couldn't cram it into 3)
Bottom
Screechy Women (AY, AD)
Too slimy by half (charlie, JF)
Last edited:
AllThatGlitters
Registered Shopper
- Joined
- Jan 21, 2009
- Messages
- 739
Thought that was it, Lottie!
Last edited:
Lottie
Silly Moo
Er yes, sorry!!! I like AK. Brain is dead today....:cheeky:
loubylou
PJ's bestie :)
- Joined
- Jan 13, 2010
- Messages
- 1,091
my top 3
1: pipa - just like her personality and as a personal thing she reminds me of my sister
2: alison keenan - lovely and warm could watch her all day
3: dale - could be controversial lol i know some people find him smarmy i don't
top 3 bottom as it were
1: julia roberts - just cannot bear the air of superiority she gives off maybe just maybe she don't realise she does but she do
2: ali young - never lets guests have a word in and is rude
3: claire - the baby voice and the baby talk she's a grown woman it don't seem right
1: pipa - just like her personality and as a personal thing she reminds me of my sister
2: alison keenan - lovely and warm could watch her all day
3: dale - could be controversial lol i know some people find him smarmy i don't
top 3 bottom as it were
1: julia roberts - just cannot bear the air of superiority she gives off maybe just maybe she don't realise she does but she do
2: ali young - never lets guests have a word in and is rude
3: claire - the baby voice and the baby talk she's a grown woman it don't seem right
Am finding everyone's lists interesting - such a difference of opinions.
My favourite three would be:
Julian - always informative with a friendly personality.
Debbie Flint - seems to be genuine, can make us laugh and still be informative, and is a "normal" size when wearing clothes.
Alison K. - so glad to see her back on QVC, long may that continue.
Bottom three:
Jill Franks - too thin for my liking! and as has been commented on before to full of herself.
Micael - just not for me.
Jilly Halliday - please, please get your hair restyled, every time I see her I want to grab a pair of scissors.
My favourite three would be:
Julian - always informative with a friendly personality.
Debbie Flint - seems to be genuine, can make us laugh and still be informative, and is a "normal" size when wearing clothes.
Alison K. - so glad to see her back on QVC, long may that continue.
Bottom three:
Jill Franks - too thin for my liking! and as has been commented on before to full of herself.
Micael - just not for me.
Jilly Halliday - please, please get your hair restyled, every time I see her I want to grab a pair of scissors.
madaunty
Quietly, Very Confused
Top 3
Debbie Flint - always (well nearly always) dresses appropriately and hair and make up always looks good. Love the filthy laugh and occasional near the knuckle humour. Her hard sell doesn't bother me 'cos if I'm not in the market to buy then I ain't being persuaded by anyone.
Julia Roberts - but only when presenting a show on her own - cannot and will not watch when she's on with a male guest and goes into full on "hair flicking and throwing back head whilst giving a girlie giggle" mode.
Julian - makes me laugh and doesn't assume we are all imbeciles who believe everything we're told
Bottom 3
Charlie - too smarmy by half and gives me the creeps when handling ladies clothing and doing his "can WE wear this with" bit... etc etc. Complete charisma bypass. Yuck Yuck Yuck
Jill Franks - as others as said, too self absorbed and completely insincere.
Plus, can remember when she was asked once if she preferred it in America or England and replied without hesitation "Oh America of course" in a tone of voice that to me suggested she couldn't wait to go there permanently. Well don't let us stop you.
And for the 3rd, am going to cheat and lump some of the blondes together,
Anna - really don't know what she's doing there, doesn't seem to fit in at all and still far too much, badly applied make up
Carmel - sort your hair out
Catherine - another one that seems too self absorbed and I hate the sickly sweet, "it may never be on 3 easy pays again sales technique
Claire - I am another one who doesn't appreciate being spoken to like a child.
Debbie Flint - always (well nearly always) dresses appropriately and hair and make up always looks good. Love the filthy laugh and occasional near the knuckle humour. Her hard sell doesn't bother me 'cos if I'm not in the market to buy then I ain't being persuaded by anyone.
Julia Roberts - but only when presenting a show on her own - cannot and will not watch when she's on with a male guest and goes into full on "hair flicking and throwing back head whilst giving a girlie giggle" mode.
Julian - makes me laugh and doesn't assume we are all imbeciles who believe everything we're told
Bottom 3
Charlie - too smarmy by half and gives me the creeps when handling ladies clothing and doing his "can WE wear this with" bit... etc etc. Complete charisma bypass. Yuck Yuck Yuck
Jill Franks - as others as said, too self absorbed and completely insincere.
Plus, can remember when she was asked once if she preferred it in America or England and replied without hesitation "Oh America of course" in a tone of voice that to me suggested she couldn't wait to go there permanently. Well don't let us stop you.
And for the 3rd, am going to cheat and lump some of the blondes together,
Anna - really don't know what she's doing there, doesn't seem to fit in at all and still far too much, badly applied make up
Carmel - sort your hair out
Catherine - another one that seems too self absorbed and I hate the sickly sweet, "it may never be on 3 easy pays again sales technique
Claire - I am another one who doesn't appreciate being spoken to like a child.
Bensmum
Registered Shopper
Yes I've thought that several times when reading threads about her, as well as Amica. I never had a particular problem with either of them, although AK has always irritated me with her constant use of the word 'clever' when describing products. I'm glad she appears to be well again, who wouldn't, but don't go overboard.
Last edited:
Top
1. JR, not because of her personality(or should I say ego) but because she is the best at the job.
2. AK - very professional
3. Julian, because he's not as full of bullish-t as most of the others
4. (I know) Debbie Flint for her naughty sense of humour
Bottom
1. JF
2. JF.
3. JF.
Why doesn't she bog off to the US and give us all a break?
1. JR, not because of her personality(or should I say ego) but because she is the best at the job.
2. AK - very professional
3. Julian, because he's not as full of bullish-t as most of the others
4. (I know) Debbie Flint for her naughty sense of humour
Bottom
1. JF
2. JF.
3. JF.
Why doesn't she bog off to the US and give us all a break?
My top three are Debbie Greenwood...I like her presenting style, she seems nice same goes for Kathy Tayler, I also like Catherine Huntley.
Don't mind Jill Franks at all, Dale Franklin, Pipa, Ali Keenan
Don't like Ali Young....She's obnoxious
Anne Dawson...just can't take to her
and Miss Piggy of course..though she's not a bad presenter when she's actually doing the job she's paid to do!
Don't mind Jill Franks at all, Dale Franklin, Pipa, Ali Keenan
Don't like Ali Young....She's obnoxious
Anne Dawson...just can't take to her
and Miss Piggy of course..though she's not a bad presenter when she's actually doing the job she's paid to do!
China Girl
Registered Shopper
- Joined
- Sep 15, 2010
- Messages
- 1,774
Agree with Gemma 1, my choice too.
- Joined
- Jun 26, 2008
- Messages
- 6,383
My top 3, in alphabetical order:
Debbie Flint, Julia Roberts and Alison Young
My bottom 3, in strict order
in 3rd place Dale, runner up: Simon Biagi, and the winner of my bottom three is...........Craig Rowe
Debbie Flint, Julia Roberts and Alison Young
My bottom 3, in strict order
in 3rd place Dale, runner up: Simon Biagi, and the winner of my bottom three is...........Craig Rowe
