To be fair the actual make up's quite good, I've found the eyeshadows a bit wishy washy when they go on, but other than that, the mascara's great, so are the lipsticks and the eye pencils...like you say...it's him! It's as though he's been scouring the archives of 70's/80's girls magazines for make up tips. I thought the make up artist's job was to enhance someone's looks, by applying a light touch..not leaving some pretty fresh faced young girl looking like she's caked in make up. Getting them to suck their cheeks in so he knows where to put the blusher ffs, Surely a credible make up artist can just see where to put it! Then just daubing matt colour onto the eyelids with little or no thought to what colour palette actually suits the model, no blending or shading. If he was a make up artist, then it must of been in the horror movie genre that's all I can surmise!