Oh, Mazza, poor you. I bet you were mortified, I'd have turned into a beetroot!
If anyone is in the market for an eye makeup remover, I use this. Been using it for years & years.
Bit of background, I can get exzema on my eyelids & also have the kind of severe allergy to certain things ( not makeup) that has seen me blue lighted into A&E with anaphylactic shock several times over the years & so I have to take antihistamines every single day if the year & carry an Epipen all the time.
So I have to be careful of irritants even though it isn't usually cosmetics that are my problem. I've never had any sort of reaction to this, or any No7 either for that matter, & you can't call it expensive!!
Only thing is it's a lotion rather than a watery liquid or oil mix type so might not appeal to everyone who doesn't like that type. It's so so gentle though & very effective. I put it on cotton wool & wipe everything off my eyes before using the face cleanser I mentioned.