Although I liked the last TSV from Mally I will use but not repurchase it. The next one looks very uninspiring. From the last set the eyeshadow stick was very good, but the smashbox long wear shadow in Gemstone is a lovely alternative. The blush was ok but a but meh, the foundation was very good but too expensive on it's own. I did like the mascara but it has started to go gloopy if it isn't given a shake, only opened it a month ago! Anyone else noticed this? I liked the eye pencil but because it doesn't retract it is now messy to use. I prefer a YBF one I got on ebay for around £3.