I have wishy washy blue eyes that go red very easily when I'm even a tad tired. Black looks too harsh on me and I have to be careful with browns - any red in them makes my redness even worse. Burgundy and I can also join the Walking Dead cast.
I did have a pencil from a Mally set that QVC did a while back and I just slapped it on when it arrived. It was a darkish coppery brown that I honestly thought would look awful, but amazingly, suits me better than anything I've tried before.
I should look on eBay for a backup as I use it quite a bit, but can't remember the name. Are the colours named on the Mally pencils? (Too lazy to look and then I probably won't be able to make it out!)