Here's my take for what it's worth. Firstly, my current bnb is powdery so not noticing much difference there. For me, the most noticeable difference (not huge tho) is the shade. I always thought that bnb was just a tad too yellow for me and the new one is definitely pinker. I did one side of my face with each and then, with trepidation, I asked He Who Notices Nothing if he could see any difference. Imagine my surprise when he said that one side is matte and one side pinker! He preferred the original but said that the difference is very small and he'd never normally have noticed. Both foundations pass the neck test but it seems that yellow based is a bit better for me after all. I will use the new one, just with a more matte blusher than usual and without my usual vanilla highlighter but probably won't buy it again.