I haven't tried it SisterBliss, I have the Pink Clay one and the smell is divine and it gives me very clear skin, I used it once or twice and this was it. I like the ingredients in it - one is kaoline clay that gets rid of impurities and is normally used in masks. I just can't get on with hot cloth cleansers as I prefer a gel face wash (Alpha-H or other). Tried other hot cloth cleansers, just not for me, but I'm trying one every now and then. The only one cleanser of this type I liked was DECIEM The Ordinary Squalane Cleanser but it's more like a balm cleanser.