No sorry never tried that one. Its so famous as the first and how the name came about. Its not only oakmoss companies buy out and make cheaper so cheaper ingredients. This totally changes a perfume. I loved chypres before I even knew about them. Femme, but it has to be the vintage without the added cumin, its a sad sad thing compared to back then. Mitsouko which they took the oakmoss out of and put tree moss in. Guerlain then pulled their socks up and in the last number of years have really worked to bring it back to its glory. I have the 1913 edp which is really gorgeous, and a 30ml parfum tester with oakmoss still in it. Balmain Jolie Madam all leather, violets and oakmoss.