No idea! The stash is used in strict chronological order! But I had a quick dab of the tester and it seemed quite nice. Not as runny as the Elemis balm but softer than it had seemed when I first had a look at it in the tub. I'm sure it.must soften up as you scoop it out etc. I bought the one in the tube as the third item. The last one of those I got was in a white tube rather than the new mauve packaging but I did like that one. At least these are cheap enough to experiment. If you buy the Elemis balm etc you need to be certain. I also like the Body Shop chamomile cleansing oil. I didn't really go for the Superdrug hot cloth cleanser and am currently trying the Boots version. It's OK as a cleanser but very highly perfumed.